Filmmaking Practice Through a Cognitive Penetration Lens – A Practitioner’s Inquiry into Implicit Social Perception

This dissertation examines how cognitive penetration—the shaping of perception by prior beliefs, experience, and knowledge—influences both filmmaking and audience perception. Although cognitive penetration can enhance expertise in professional contexts, it can also distort social perception, reinforce xenophobia, and contribute to conflict. These effects become especially pronounced under conditions of uncertainty or ambiguity, when perception depends more heavily on internal knowledge. As film and media increasingly serve as primary sources of information about social groups, filmmakers play an important role in shaping viewers’ prior beliefs. Despite its significance, cognitive penetration has not yet been systematically examined in relation to filmmaking and film perception. Drawing on cognitive film theory, social neuroscience, and practice-based artistic research, this dissertation extends Neurocinematics by investigating cognitive penetration from a filmmaker’s perspective. Through interdisciplinary experiments, neuroscientific analysis, and artistic practice, it examines whether knowledge acquired through film can evoke implicit social bias and whether such effects can be detected in implicit neural processing. It also explores how filmmakers’ dramaturgical expertise can enrich the interpretation of neural data collected during film viewing, how collaboration with neuroscientists can inform filmmaking practices aimed at reducing the misrepresentation of social groups, and how findings on ambiguous image perception can be translated into cinematic form. The dissertation produced five peer-reviewed articles, two artistic works, and two novel scientific methods for investigating and interpreting implicit social perception through film. Its findings deepen understanding of the neural mechanisms underlying implicit social bias, demonstrate the value of integrating filmmaker expertise into neuroscientific research, and show how evidence informed filmmaking can help reduce biased representations of social groups. In doing so, the study advances understanding of cognitive penetration and its significance for filmmaking practice and pedagogy.

This publication uses Eye Tracking, Facial Expression Analysis, fMRI and GSR which is fully integrated into iMotions Lab

Learn more

Other publications you might be interested in